jump to navigation

Should Coders Learn to Test? July 8, 2015

Posted by Peter Varhol in Software development.
Tags: ,
trackback

This topic occurred to me in response to another posting that asked if testers should learn to code, and is a follow-on to my previous post on the unique skill set that software testers possess. If we seriously question whether testers should learn to code (and most opinions fall on the ‘yes’ side of this question), then it is relevant to ask the corresponding question.

Wait a minute, I hear you thinking. That’s a stupid question. Coders already know how to test; they are coders, after all. Testing is simply a subset of coding, the act of making sure that the code that they have written works properly.

It’s nice to believe that coders know how to test because they know how to code, but that’s fallacious reasoning. First, it’s a different skill set entirely. Coding is highly detail-oriented and focused on making sure the code is grammatically and logically correct. Testing asks whether that code covers all requirements, is usable, and is fit for its intended purpose.

Second, while it’s a cliché that coders can’t test their own code, that doesn’t make it any less true. I’ve tested my own code, and I shy away from edge cases or unusual inputs. Testers bravely go where coders don’t.

Third, testers do much more than checking code for logic bugs. Because of their broad mandate encompassing correctness as well as domain expertise and information from end users, testers must be both detail-oriented and focused on the end result, yet able to be flexible in terms of their goals.

So should coders learn the skills of testers? The answer is, of course, it depends. We should all be learning additional skills, but only have a finite amount of time, so there is a cost/benefit tradeoff for any professional in learning (and presumably practicing) a collateral skill. By learning how to test, coders by necessity have to reduce time learning a new language, or learning continuous integration, for example.

But there are technical advantages for coders to learn testing. At the very least, it will make them more thoughtful coders. At best, it can help them write better code, as they become experienced with knowing what testers look for.

If coders do decide to learn to test, they have to give up certain biases to effectively learn the skill set. Here are just a few of those biases.

  1. Users would never do that! That’s simply not true. Users will do everything you can imagine and many things you can’t.
  2. It’s not a bug, it’s a feature. Stop arguing, and start working together to determine if it’s a feature needed by the users.
  3. Testers just slow us down. That may be true in some cases, but most of the time testers speed up the application delivery process. If they seem to slow you down, perhaps it’s because developers didn’t do their jobs right to begin with.

Probably the best way for coders to learn how to test is to do pair-testing with an experienced tester. Participating in testing with someone who already has the skill set will help a developer learn how to spot weaknesses in their code, how end users approach their tasks with software, and how to assess risks and determine testing strategies.

The goal isn’t to turn coders into testers, but to make them better coders. For many coders, that’s a skill worth having.

Advertisements

Comments»

1. Dani Almog - July 13, 2015

Do the coder must know how to test his code ? it is a dumb question – he must.
But the problem is that we expect him to be able to test the application or the product he produced. This where we may argue. For me the latter need more than coding skills.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: